On Mentoring
Sunday, August 9th, 2009
I went tonight to see Julie and Julia, re-envisioned from Julie Powell’s book of the same name to be a funny, moving intertwining of the aspirations of two women: chef Julia Child as she struggles to become a chef and, later, to publish Mastering the Art of French Cooking, and Julie Powell, an aspiring writer who decides to blog about her experiences cooking her way through Child’s oeuvre.
My companion identified one key theme that emerges from the film: the level of validation that both Julia and Julie find through writing. And for those of us who have been on that journey (in our own little ways - nothing that compares with the bestselling qualities of both of the protagonists’ books), it’s a resonant theme. There is something magical about being validated from outside. It’s part of why I love to see SLMS get published - it’s so validating to see that others have respected what you have to say.
But as I reflected, I realized that it’s also about something else: about finding someone who mentors you and helps you to grow. Though Julia Child is not a formal mentor (she actually did not like Powell’s blog very much, and they never communicated), she is a clear influence on Powell. We have those kinds of mentors in our profession: the folks we may not have met but who influence us through their articles, their blogs, their books, their keynotes, or their webinars. They urge us to keep moving forward and, like Child’s recipes, give us some ideas for how to scaffold that journey. Other mentors are those we know well, those that we chat with at department meetings, over coffee, or in the hallways. Those mentors often are less “inspirational” and more in the problem-solving mode. And boy oh boy, do we need both.
The movie made me reflect on those who have mentored me both locally as I develop my teaching craft and nationally as I stretch beyond my school. Those who are too busy to answer my emails chock full of naive questions but answer them thoughtfully anyway. Those who, in picking up their class from a fixed-schedule class, hint at a different strategy for classroom management or for viewing a kid with whom I’m struggling. Those administrators who help me by validating (or shooting down!) my ideas as I move into a new half-time role next year as a staff development facilitator.
What’s the point of this late-night rambling? I guess there are a few:
- Find mentors: local master teachers, inspirational national figures, even folks outside the profession whose perspective on another field gives us a new lens through which to see our own. Mentors help you know that you’re not alone and form a network that we all need. Most of us haven’t had formal mentors since our student teaching, practicum, or pre-tenure days. We need them!
- Be a mentor: take on a student teacher and/or share your expertise with a district colleague, at a conference, or in your own writing.
As we head into the new school year, and we return to face the many pressures and tensions that unfortunately can accompany our profession at this tough time, it’s good to know where your mentors are.
And if you haven’t read Powell’s book, I highly recommend it. It’s funny and real and irreverent.
I went tonight to see Julie and Julia, re-envisioned from Julie Powell’s book of the same name to be a funny, moving intertwining of the aspirations of two women: chef Julia Child as she struggles to become a chef and, later, to publish Mastering the Art of French Cooking, and Julie Powell, an aspiring writer who decides to blog about her experiences cooking her way through Child’s oeuvre.
My companion identified one key theme that emerges from the film: the level of validation that both Julia and Julie find through writing. And for those of us who have been on that journey (in our own little ways - nothing that compares with the bestselling qualities of both of the protagonists’ books), it’s a resonant theme. There is something magical about being validated from outside. It’s part of why I love to see SLMS get published - it’s so validating to see that others have respected what you have to say.
But as I reflected, I realized that it’s also about something else: about finding someone who mentors you and helps you to grow. Though Julia Child is not a formal mentor (she actually did not like Powell’s blog very much, and they never communicated), she is a clear influence on Powell. We have those kinds of mentors in our profession: the folks we may not have met but who influence us through their articles, their blogs, their books, their keynotes, or their webinars. They urge us to keep moving forward and, like Child’s recipes, give us some ideas for how to scaffold that journey. Other mentors are those we know well, those that we chat with at department meetings, over coffee, or in the hallways. Those mentors often are less “inspirational” and more in the problem-solving mode. And boy oh boy, do we need both.
The movie made me reflect on those who have mentored me both locally as I develop my teaching craft and nationally as I stretch beyond my school. Those who are too busy to answer my emails chock full of naive questions but answer them thoughtfully anyway. Those who, in picking up their class from a fixed-schedule class, hint at a different strategy for classroom management or for viewing a kid with whom I’m struggling. Those administrators who help me by validating (or shooting down!) my ideas as I move into a new half-time role next year as a staff development facilitator.
What’s the point of this late-night rambling? I guess there are a few:
- Find mentors: local master teachers, inspirational national figures, even folks outside the profession whose perspective on another field gives us a new lens through which to see our own. Mentors help you know that you’re not alone and form a network that we all need. Most of us haven’t had formal mentors since our student teaching, practicum, or pre-tenure days. We need them!
- Be a mentor: take on a student teacher and/or share your expertise with a district colleague, at a conference, or in your own writing.
As we head into the new school year, and we return to face the many pressures and tensions that unfortunately can accompany our profession at this tough time, it’s good to know where your mentors are.
And if you haven’t read Powell’s book, I highly recommend it. It’s funny and real and irreverent.






