My friend Laura is looking for a districtwide read for her incoming sixth graders. With permission, her original post is republished below. Can you help?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
My school district has been awarded a grant to provide resources for summer reading to each of our rising fifth graders. Each student will be allowed to choose seven books that will be sent to their homes over the summer based on their personal interests and reading level. In addition, all students will be sent one common book. We are hoping to provide a book that will be a springboard to discussions that will continue throughout the 2010-2011 school year.In order to select this book, our administrator provided a list as a starting point and asked us to recommend other titles that we might want to consider. This is her list (taken from the March issue ofEducational Leadership):
Gone by Michael Grant
Heat by Mike Lupica
The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins
Leviathan by Scott Westerfeld
The Lightning Thief by Rick Riordan
The London Eye Mystery by Siobhan Dowd
Masterpiece by Elise Broach
The Maze of Bones by Rick Riordan
The Maze Runner by James Dashner
NERDS: National Espionage, Rescue, and Defense Society by Michael Buckley
Peak by Roland Smith
Stormbreaker by Anthony Horowicz
When You Reach Me by Rebecca Stead
When I first saw this list, I was inclined to remove several titles immediately for several reasons. One reason is that a book might fit better at another grade level in terms of content or curriculum. The Lightning Thief is an example of this. I have a seventh grade social studies teacher who uses this title as part of his study of mythology. He gets students interested and excited about his subject using this book. I don’t want to usurp his work with our book choice.
Although I love The Hunger Games, it’s also off my final list. I’m not sure it’s a book for every 10-year-old. There are many heavy issues that take discussion to fully grasp. I also think it’s over-exposed and will only become more so when Mockingjay and the movie are released. I would rather see a title that not every student will be exposed to chosen for this purpose.
Finally, The Maze of Bones is not a book I would choose because it is one in a series of 10. It is not a complete story on its own and it would take nine additional books to “finish” this one. I prefer to offer a book that is either stand-alone or part of a much shorter series.
The question becomes, “Where do I go from here?” I have enlisted a group of teachers to work with me on making our recommendations. We are reading any books we have not from the above list. We also created another list of books that we are reading as well. The new list includes:
Anything But Typical by Nora Raleigh Baskin
Heart of a Shepherd by Roseanne Parry
Leaving the Bellweathers by Kristin Clark Venuti
The Girl Who Threw Butterflies by Mick Chochrane
Captain Nobody by Dean Pitchford
Operation Yes by Sara Lewis Holmes
We are reading these titles as well in hopes of adding to the original selections and offering a few more options. Once we have read them all, I’m hoping to have some rich discussions about which book we will choose and why it will be important to all sixth graders.
What do you think? If all of your sixth graders could read one common book, what would it be? Is it on our list? If so, let us know what it is and why. If not, let us know what titles we should add for consideration!